Plausible isn’t the same as proven


21st September 2026

Newsletter Monday

Hello Reader,

For as long as I have been a GP, pregnant women have asked me about peanuts.

“Should I avoid eating nuts while I’m pregnant?”

Usually because they’ve heard that eating peanuts during pregnancy might make their baby more likely to develop a peanut allergy.

And, actually, this didn’t originate with TikTok, Instagram or somebody selling a pregnancy nutrition course.

We did say it.

Until 2009, UK government advice suggested that women might want to avoid peanuts during pregnancy and breastfeeding if there was a family history of allergic disease.

It sounded plausible.

Peanuts cause peanut allergy. Perhaps exposing a developing baby to peanut proteins increases their chances of becoming allergic to them.

Except the evidence didn’t support the advice, so it was eventually withdrawn.

Today, the NHS advice is quite straightforward: unless you are allergic to them yourself, you don’t need to avoid peanuts during pregnancy or breastfeeding.

But health warnings have a remarkably long half-life.

Once we have told people that something might be harmful, removing the warning doesn’t necessarily remove the fear.

Eggs know all about this.🥚

We spent years warning people about eggs because they contain cholesterol. The advice moved on a very long time ago, yet I still regularly encounter people carefully rationing their eggs because somewhere in the back of their mind is a health message they absorbed in the 1980s.

Once an idea gets lodged in our collective health consciousness, good luck getting the wretched thing out again.

And I think this matters particularly during pregnancy.

Because pregnancy comes with an extraordinary weight of responsibility.

Suddenly what you eat, drink and do isn’t just about you. Every decision has the potential to be framed in terms of what it might do to another human being for the rest of their life.

Eat this.
Don’t eat that.
Take this supplement.
Avoid this ingredient.
Do this and you might reduce your baby’s risk of X.
Fail to do this and you might increase their risk of Y.

And if something subsequently does happen to your child, it is remarkably easy to look backwards and wonder whether you caused it.

That is an enormous burden to place on women.

Which is why I think we should be very careful before adding anything else to the pregnancy to-do list.

And this week, a fascinating study published in the New England Journal of Medicine did exactly what good science should do: it tested another entirely plausible idea.

We now have good evidence that introducing foods such as peanut appropriately during infancy, rather than deliberately delaying them, can reduce the risk of allergy.

So researchers asked an obvious question.

Could we go even earlier?

What if mothers ate lots of peanuts and eggs during pregnancy and breastfeeding? Could exposure through pregnancy and breast milk help the developing immune system become tolerant and reduce the baby’s chance of developing an allergy?

You can already imagine the Instagram reel.

“Pregnant? Here are TWO foods you should be eating to protect your baby from allergies…”

Add some pictures of peanut butter and scrambled eggs, mention “supporting your baby’s developing immune system”, put some uplifting music underneath it and we’re away.

Except somebody actually tested it.

More than 2,100 pregnant women whose babies were considered at increased familial risk of allergy were randomly allocated to one of two groups before 23 weeks of pregnancy.

One group was asked to consume at least six eggs and 60 peanuts every week.

Sixty peanuts.

Every week.

They continued doing this through pregnancy and for four months after birth while breastfeeding.

The comparison group ate substantially less.

Then the researchers looked at how many babies had developed an IgE-mediated egg or peanut allergy by the age of one.

In the high egg-and-peanut group: 7.8%.

In the comparison group: 8.4%.

In other words, no convincing difference.

Eating industrial quantities of omelettes and peanuts during pregnancy did not prevent food allergy.

And I love this study precisely because nothing exciting happened.

Because negative trials matter.

They stop plausible ideas becoming instructions.

There was absolutely nothing ridiculous about the hypothesis. In fact, it made enough biological sense for researchers to conduct a large randomised controlled trial to find out whether it was true.

But “this makes biological sense” and “therefore you should do it” are two very different things.

And this is where modern health advice can get itself into such a mess.

A plausible mechanism gets discussed.

Somebody turns it into a recommendation.

The recommendation becomes a reel.

The reel becomes “five things EVERY pregnant woman should be doing”.

And several million views later, an interesting scientific hypothesis has somehow become another thing for women to worry about.

The person giving the advice doesn’t necessarily have to come back five or ten years later and say:

“Remember that thing I confidently told you to do? Turns out it made no difference.”

They’ve moved on.

Science, frustratingly slowly, has to stick around and find out.

Of course, science has been responsible for some of this mess too. The old advice to avoid peanuts is a perfect example.

That’s why I think we need to be more comfortable saying:

“We don’t know.”

Or:

“That is plausible, but it hasn’t been demonstrated.”

Neither makes a particularly exciting Instagram reel. But both are considerably more honest.

For now, the advice for pregnant women regarding peanuts is wonderfully boring.

  • If you’re not allergic to them and you like them, you can eat them.
  • If you don’t like them, you don’t need to force down 60 a week on behalf of your unborn child’s immune system.

And if anyone tells you that something “makes biological sense”, remember:

That’s an excellent reason to study it.

It’s a considerably less good reason to tell millions of people to start doing it.

Remember your body is the greatest thing you will ever own.

Look after it, train it and keep moving.

Thank you for reading.

See you same time, next week.

Lynette

P.s Thank you to those reply to my emails, I love to hear your feedback, but unfortunately can't respond to everyone.

​

Catch the latest podcast episode

Why strength training is GOOD for your heart

I'm joined by Emily McGrath from the British Heart Foundation for this conversation.

video preview​
show
Why Strength Training Is Goo...
Sep 15 · The Prescription Strengt...
42:14
Spotify Logo
 
​

LE8 9EF. Leicestershire.
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Prescription Strength

Health headlines without the hype. A weekly dose of medical insight, common sense and occasional sarcasm from a GP who’s seen it all

Read more from Prescription Strength

9th November 2026 Newsletter Monday Hot buttered toast- a simple joy Reader Some time ago, I wrote a post about those cholesterol-lowering spreads you can buy in the supermarket. You know the ones. Benecol and its team mates. The central claim made about these products isn’t false. They contain plant sterols, which have been shown to lower LDL cholesterol. However, despite being around for decades, we don’t see good evidence from clinical trials that using these products reduces your chances...

2nd November 2026 Newsletter Monday Just hilarious I spent last night laughing until my face hurt at Kevin Bridges who performed at Nottingham arena, and I’m still laughing about some of his jokes this morning. I’m mentioning it here because, amongst all that humour, were some rather sharp observations that connected with things I’d been thinking about over the weekend. On Saturday, I listened to Harvard evolutionary biologist Daniel Lieberman talking to Michael Easter on his podcast about...

26th October 2026 Newsletter Monday Another day, another headline Do you remember the time when we knew remarkably little about the health of famous people? Occasionally, a celebrity’s health would become mainstream news. Perhaps a well-known actor had developed cancer, or a musician had a condition serious enough to threaten their career. Otherwise, their medical histories were largely their own business. Perhaps something might have been revealed during an interview with Michael Parkinson...